Welcome to Uncle Vinny's NY Pizzeria
At Uncle Vinny's NY Pizzeria, the story begins with a passion for authentic New York-style pizza right in the heart of Broken Arrow, Oklahoma. With recipes that honor traditional flavors, the menu features an array of delights, from crispy, cheesy slices to mouthwatering calzones. Guests rave about the chewy, toasty crust and the inviting atmosphere; it’s a place where community thrives. Friendly staff and local charm elevate your dining experience. With the signature hot oil and an array of toppings, every bite is a taste of the Big Apple. Uncle Vinny's is more than a pizzeria; it’s a gathering spot, celebrating great food and good vibes.
-
322 W Kenosha St, Broken Arrow, OK 74012, United States Hotline: +1 918-251-6666
Welcome to Uncle Vinny's NY Pizzeria, a gem tucked away at 322 W Kenosha St, Broken Arrow, OK. This delightful establishment has carved a niche for itself in the hearts of locals, who rave about its authentic New York-style pizza. As soon as you walk in, the warm, inviting atmosphere and friendly staff make you feel right at home. Each visit is accompanied by a sense of nostalgia, reminiscent of bustling NYC pizzerias, yet filtered through a uniquely welcoming Broken Arrow lens.
Uncle Vinny's prides itself on delivering a menu brimming with traditional Italian flavors. From the first bite of their perfectly baked pizza crust—chewy and toasty—to the rich, savory toppings, every dish tantalizes the taste buds. Customer reviews echo a common sentiment: this pizzeria serves some of the best pizza in Oklahoma.
- Pizza: Available by the slice or as a whole pie, their pepperoni and meat pizzas are fan favorites. Diners have praised the quality of ingredients and consistency of flavor, a testament to the authentic recipes that pay homage to New York’s finest.
- Calzones and Stromboli: Ideal for those seeking a stuffed delight, the calzones deliver creamy ricotta alongside a medley of savory fillings, while the stromboli offers a customizable option loaded with fresh toppings.
- Garlic Knots and Sides: Complement your meal with their mouthwatering garlic knots or cheesy bread. Customers can't get enough of the hot oil dipping sauce; it’s a must-try that elevates the dining experience.
- Sandwiches: Don't miss the meatball and Italian combo sandwiches, each crafted with love and bold flavors that leave diners craving more.
What sets Uncle Vinny's NY Pizzeria apart is not only its incredible food but also its commitment to community. The pay-it-forward board encourages diners to partake in acts of kindness, showcasing the heart of this local pizzeria. Whether you're grabbing a slice on the go or dining in, it’s hard not to be drawn in by the infectious enthusiasm of the staff.
Each visit to Uncle Vinny's transforms a simple meal into an experience infused with flavor and fellowship. So, whether you're a local resident or just passing through, make sure to stop by for a slice (or two). You'll soon understand why so many proclaim it as the best New York-style pizza in Oklahoma!
This is the best pizza in Oklahoma as far as I'm concerned. As a recent Oklahoma transplant I didn't expect to find pizza this good here. Lots of other places claiming to be authentic NYC style but this is the real deal. The staff is really nice and the price is right. Highly recommend.
Excellent pizza and great place to get it! I love the crust. It's chewy and toasty The breadsticks are fantastic It's fresh food. They also sell by the slice or whole! The cheese cake selection is pretty good too! I'm glad I went! Cool thing... they also have a pay it forward board I love this place
The best NY style pizza I’ve found in Oklahoma! By the slice or the whole pie, I had both, pepperoni by the slice on the spot and a whole meat pizza to go, would highly recommend both with a little hot oil
One of my favorite pizza places. Nice little BA neighborhood gem. Everything I’ve ordered here has been so good. Staff is super friendly and they work really hard. Recommend trying the hot oil as least once, it’s great. Support local!
I highly recommend this place, specifically for their pizza. Truly a gem for BA! Their cheese pizza was so flavorful and actually tasted like NYC pizza. Alot of pizza shops claim NYC but it's no where close. This place delivers what I'm expecting! Everyone needs to run here and eat! A
I have been reading all the reviews for a while now about Uncle Vinny's. I live in Brookside though, so I've always said I'll go eventually as I don't wander off to Broken Arrow often for food. I ordered a large Piso Pie, Ravioli, and Garlic Knots. The food was ready quickly only about 25 minutes. When I arrived the dinning room had a few guests, was clean and well maintained. The staff were friendly and helpful. I was promised I'd enjoy my pizza-- they were right! I wish I had just stopped for a piece there. I was starving and still had to run an errand before I would get home to eat, but I couldn't help myself the pizza smelled so good. I had a slice in the car. Watch out for the hot oil - it tastes great, but you'll need a napkin or two. When I got home after my errand, I was delighted that the ravioli and pizza were still hot and really good. The ravioli is classic ricotta which was exactly what I was craving. Overall, I will absolutely travel out to Broken Arrow again for pizza, but I think I'll do it on a night I can eat in or at least don't have to eat in my car.
Excellent pizza and the people are so friendly! Pepperoni/mushroom/fresh mozzarella is our favorite combo, and the garlic knots are amazing as well. I'm *obsessed* with the hot oil. The salads are huge and have lots of goodies. Pretty much everything on the menu is delish.
Looking for a lunch idea and googled for food in the small area we were in. Came across this little place. It was so good. The pizza slices were the perfect size and the toppings were so good. I got bacon onion and green pepper and the bacon was SO good. We will definitely be going back and this time I'm getting cheesecake or a cannoli (sp).